Critical Thinking Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 10

Critical Thinking - Essay Example The article â€Å"Yes: It Provides Protection for Children,† written by Steve Francis and Gayle Francis, assert that teenagers cannot make this abortion decision on their own, and so they need their parents or adults to help them get through this crisis. Steve Francis and Gayle Francis argue that Proposition 4 will be good for concerned teenagers, parents, and society in general. It will be good for teenagers, because they can access the emotional and social support that their parents or adult family members can give them. Francis and Francis assert that during these sensitive times, girls need their parents to help them cope with physical and psychological trauma of abortion. Furthermore, they emphasize that this proposition will protect girls from male predators, who will force them to do an abortion. Parents will also benefit from this proposition, because they can ensure that their children receive quality health care, including post-operation health care services. Francis and Francis argue, too, that states with parental involvement laws have lower percentages of teen pregnancies, abortions and sexually transmitted infections than states without these laws. Finally, they underline that this proposition is good for society, beca use it is aligned to existing laws that protect the youth from sexual predators and it can ensure that the youth will not have to make this hard decision on their own. The strength of this article is that it wants to ensure that teenagers get enough social support when making life-changing decisions. It suggests sincere belief in the paternal role of the state in protecting the welfare of the youth. Their article, however, possesses several fallacies, specifically overgeneralization, statement of opinion as facts, and weak inductive argument. Francis and Francis give an example of a 13-year-old girl from the San Francisco Bay Area. A 39-year-old man got her pregnant and brought her to a clinic for an abortion. A few days after, the